Saraiki and the other Punjabs

The Punjab of 1901 held more than the language of Amritsar and Lahore. Saraiki was spoken across Multan, Bahawalpur, Muzaffargarh and the Derajat. Hindko was spoken at Peshawar and in Hazara. Pothohari was spoken in the north.

Whether Saraiki is a dialect of Punjabi or a separate language is a live political question in Pakistan, tied to a long-running demand for a separate Saraiki province out of southern Punjab. The 2017 census recorded Saraiki separately.

That question is the mirror image of the argument in Indian Punjab in the 1950s about whether Punjabi and Hindi were distinct, which was settled politically rather than linguistically.

A language boundary in this region has never been a linguistic fact alone. Where a dialect chain is cut, and what the pieces are called, follows what people want the boundary to do.

Bahawalpur and Multan carry a literature, a music and a Sufi tradition of their own, and Punjab's history as usually told from Amritsar or Lahore leaves out about a third of the province.

It has its own script conventions, its own Sufi poets, Khwaja Ghulam Farid above all, and its own literary societies, and it has been counted separately in the Pakistani census since 1981. Whatever the linguists conclude, an official form that offers it as a box to tick has already settled the matter in practice.

The demand for a southern Punjab province is carried in Saraiki, and the argument is about the concentration of the province's resources in the central districts.

Hindko in Hazara and Pothohari in Rawalpindi are the northern equivalents. Punjab as a province contains at least four things that could be called separate languages if their speakers wanted them to be.

What we don't know

  • The classification question itself, which is not resolvable on linguistic grounds alone.

Where to check this

  1. Pakistan census language data. Census of India 2011 - Punjab district census handbooks ↗

Named but not linked. These are real, findable documents. This project has not consulted them for this page.

  • Linguistic literature on the Punjabi-Saraiki continuum.

This page has not yet been read through by the editor. Treat it with more caution than the rest.

How this page was written. The text is compiled from the standard published histories and reference works, not from a document held in hand. Nobody from this project has visited the place or read the archive. The list above is where a reader can go to check it, not a record of what was consulted line by line. Dates and figures are the received account. If you hold something better, write in and it will be corrected.

This is one of 62 accounts in What the Voice Carried, the chapter of this site covering the poetry, the music and the oral tradition.